I have been told, a time or two, that chastising bad performance doesn’t help. And, I try not to do that. But is it good to only be positive? I don’t know. You know, I’d like to complain, but… So, it’s worth talking about; let me do so.
In general, my approach is to point out why certain approaches are common, but don’t work. However, I try to always couple that with what does work. I do agree that just complaining isn’t helpful (well, in the big picture; it may make you feel good in the moment ;). You can talk about why an approach isn’t helpful, ideally explicitly but even implicitly, but it needs to be coupled with an explanation of what would help.
Could we, or should we, only provide the positive? I can see the appeal, but then how do you remediate if people take the wrong inference or make a mistake? For things where people are liable to misinterpret, can we proactively ensure that’s not going to happen? I’m not sure without showing the mistake, but I’m willing to be wrong.
Interestingly, I recently read that people care more for avoiding bad leaders than having good ones. Does that hold for critiques in other areas? Would folks rather have at least minimally competent learning rather than all the bells and whistles? I would think so! Which suggests designing learning to a minimum standard of competence rather than expending effort on good production values. Certainly, we’ve heard that video can be less than stellar if it’s effetive.
Yet, we see people ‘like’ing courses that make them feel good, but aren’t effective. Live or asynchronous, it doesn’t seem to matter. What people think is good learning, and what actually is effective, has essentially zero correlation (.09, which is zero with a rounding error, as I’ve been known to say). Which does suggest educating folks about learning, which I’ve previously suggested!
Of course, folks might not actually know what good leadership is. Certainly, there’s a lot of ‘BS‘ out there. The study did look at comparing people with good competence and morality versus bad on those dimensions, but it was an artificial setup. Still, that they’d avoid the bad more than pursue the good is interesting.
One thing I think that folks do seem to know is to avoid bad learning experiences. We hear about auto-clickers or paying people to take it for busy folks, or not attending training. Of course, folks also are self-helping, ineffectively.
I’d like to complain, but complaining alone doesn’t help. Pointing out errors and providing remedial feedback, however, is effective learning practice, so maybe it’s good form as well? I welcome your thoughts.
Leave a Reply